It’s Halloween and all the Cry Babies are getting ready for the party with amazing costumes. Coney bumps into Agatha, a very clumsy witch who has a talking cat! Unintentionally, they mis up their broomsticks and Coney only realizes because Agatha’s broomstick is magical and can fly. When she tells all the other Cry Babies no one believes the story: witches and talking cats don’t exist! Will Coney get to prove them everything she is telling is true?